Mapping Impactful Media Literacy Practices

Extensive research over the past decades has found media literacy education to positively impact learners’ ability to critique and create media. This research takes place across academic disciplines and within a variety of formal and informal education settings.

This project builds on this wealth of past work to explore how media literacy research and practice identifies and measures impact, and how the language of equity and inclusion exists in media literacy educational practice in the United States.

The values that guide this project are as follows:

  • Media literacy practices prioritize marginalized and underserved communities.
  • Media literacy practices prioritize just and equitable futures.
  • Media literacy practices are guided by caring ethics.
  • Media literacy practices encourage experimentation, risk-taking, play, and failure.
  • Media literacy practices are nourishing, supportive, inclusive, and respectful.
A cartoonish drawing of a boy tending a garden

Throughout this project we interrogate three longstanding assumptions of media literacy practice:

  1. Media literacy prioritizes individual agency

    What skills, habits, attitudes, and behaviors should media literate people demonstrate? And how?

  2. Media literacy empowers communities

    What media literacy practices support trust, equity, care, and participation across communities? And particularly those at the margins of society?

  3. Media literacy supports democracy

    What democractic norms does media literacy support? For whom? And what should media literacy aspire to?

To address these assumptions, this project advances an “ecosystem approach” to research that is comprised of the following three phases:

A cartoonish drawing of a young woman carrying a bag full of carrots and bread. The bag has the words "Save the Earth" on it.
1

Scoping Review

Despite the increasing research into media literacy interventions across primary, secondary and higher education in the United States, there has been little consensus on what makes interventions impactful, and how that impact should be measured.

In the first phase of this project, we conduct a scoping review of media literacy interventions in the United States over the last decade to identify and highlight what how impact is defined and approached in media literacy practice.

Based on the findings of the systematic literature review, we identified a core set of indicators for impactful media literacy practices, which we used to interview media literacy stakeholders across the United States.

A cartoonish drawing of a professorial-looking person in front of a chalkboard. They are holding a red book with the title "Civic Media", and the chalkboard has the words "How can media literacy be used to empower diverse voices?" on it.

2

Learning from Media Literacy Stakeholders

To learn more about how impact and equity are understood in media literacy learning environments, our team conducted 27 in-depth interviews with media literacy stakeholders around the United States. These conversations helped us further understand how organizational leaders, community advocates, teachers and administrators think about impact in their space, or work, and how they connect that to issues of equity and inclusion.

We used these insights to design and distribute a national survey to over 750 media literacy practitioners to learn more about how their practices support equity and inclusion, and what they see as the major opportunities and challenges for media literacy education to support more equity-driven learning experiences in classrooms and communities.

A cartoonish drawing of the side-view of the bottom three-quarters of a woman's head. On the other top quarter above her head are drawings of a wifi signal symbol, flowers and plants, and circles, as well as a red thought bubble that has the words "How does this make me feel?" in it.
3

A Field Guide for Equitable Media Literacy Practice

The results of our exploration show a clear need to offer resources to support media literacy practitioners develop, design, and implement more equity-focus media literacy practices in their learning environments. To do so, from our research we created a Field Guide for Equitable Media Literacy Practice, which offers resources, activities and approaches to consider how media literacies can be more equity- and inclusion-oriented. The field guide is open and accessible for all, and guides users through five sections that offer a holitistic approach to media literacy practices that can focus on care, inclusion and equity

Contact

  • For inquiries with NAMLE, contact: Michelle Ciulla Lipkin: mciullalipkin[at]namle.net
  • For inquiries regarding the Mapping Impactful Media Literacy Project contact: Paul Mihailidis: paul_mihailidis[at]emerson.edu

Mapping Impactful Media Literacy Practices

Initial support for the research project is made possible through the National Association for Media Literacy Education and Facebook. To ensure the independence and integrity of this research effort, NAMLE maintains full authority regarding project strategy, budget, personnel decisions, or research activities. Facebook has no control over the research design, methodology, analysis, or findings. NAMLE and any research authors will maintain exclusive copyright over all products and freely disseminate those products to advance the media literacy field.

For inquiries with NAMLE, contact Michelle Ciulla Lipkin: mciullalipkin[at]namle.net.
For inquiries regarding the Mapping Impactful Media Literacy Project, contact Paul Mihailidis: paul_mihailidis[at]emerson.edu.

Logo for National Association for Media Literacy Education (NAMLE)